1990-91 Earl of Eldon beat Hurley Town Casuals 3-2
1991-92 Robin Hood Rovers beat Farnham Town 2-1
1992-93 Horley Town Casuals beat Strollers 2-0
1993-94 Manor Athletic beat Merstham (AET) 5-2
1994-95 Horley Town Casuals beat Strollers 1-0
1995-96 Merstham beat Horley Town Casuals 3-0
1996-97 Warlingham beat Manor Athletic 3-1
1997-98 Warlingham beat Robin Hood Rovers 4-1
1998-99 Warlingham beat Reigate Priory 3-1
1999-2000 Manor Athletic beat Robin Hood Rovers 4-2
2000-01 Manor Athletic beat Morden Nomads 1-0
2001-02 Whyteleafe beat Battersea Vets 4-0 a.e.t
2002-03 Whyteleafe beat Sutton Utd 4-1
2003-04 Whyteleafe beat Cherry Tree Athletic 3-1
2004-05 Manor Athletic beat Hampton Village 2-1
2005-06 Cherry Tree Athletic beat Hamton Village 2-0
2006-07 Manor Athletic beat Milford & Witley 6-0